Back to all products
Menstrual Products Guide: Which Is Best for You?
Menstrual DiscVSPeriod Underwear
Two good options, side by side. See the differences and choose what suits you best.
Newer Option
Menstrual Disc
4.5
“A modern alternative to the cup. It has a large capacity, is excellent for heavy flow, and is often comfortable for those with strong cramps.”
Pros
- ✓ Less likely to leak, even on heavy days
- ✓ Excellent for cramps, as it eases pelvic pressure
- ✓ Larger capacity than the cup
- ✓ Reusable versions available
- ✓ Can be worn for up to 12 hours
Cons
- ✗ Learning curve for insertion
- ✗ Can be a little messy to remove
- ✗ More expensive than disposable tampons
- ✗ Less available in pharmacies
Most Comfortable
Period Underwear
4.6
“The most comfortable option on the market. Feels like normal underwear, is sustainable, and perfect for light to moderate flow or as backup.”
Pros
- ✓ As comfortable as normal underwear
- ✓ Reusable, sustainable, and economical
- ✓ No Toxic Shock risk
- ✓ Great for light flow and as extra backup
- ✓ Various absorbencies available
- ✓ No insertion needed: ideal for anyone not comfortable with it
Cons
- ✗ Higher initial investment
- ✗ Requires careful washing and takes time to dry
- ✗ May not be enough for very heavy flow
- ✗ You need 5 to 7 pairs for a full cycle
Feature Comparison
Detailed side-by-side analysis
| Feature | Menstrual Disc | Period Underwear |
|---|---|---|
| Good for a first period | Better a bit later on | Yes, very easy |
| Usage Type | Internal | External |
| Vaginal Insertion | Yes (fornix) | No |
| Sustainability | High (reusable version) | Maximum |
| Wear Time | Up to 12 hours | 8 to 12 hours (depends on flow) |
| Product Lifespan | Up to 2 years (reusable) | 2 to 5 years |
| Monthly Cost | $2 to 7 (reusable) | $2 to 8 (after the initial purchase) |
| Learning Curve | Medium | None |
| Best For | Heavy flow and strong cramps | Light or moderate flow, nights, backup |
| Physical Activity | All activities, including swimming | Walking and yoga (not swimming) |
| Toxic Shock Risk | Very low | None |
| Material | Medical silicone or plastic (disposable) | Microfiber, cotton, absorbent layers |