Back to all products
Menstrual Products Guide: Which Is Best for You?
Pad with WingsVSMenstrual Disc
Two good options, side by side. See the differences and choose what suits you best.
Most Common
Pad with Wings
4
“Ideal for those who are just starting to menstruate. Wings provide extra security and reduce the risk of side leaks.”
Pros
- ✓ Extremely easy to use, with no insertion required
- ✓ Wings secure the pad safely to your underwear
- ✓ Widely available at pharmacies and supermarkets
- ✓ Great for heavy flow days
- ✓ Available in various absorbencies (light, regular, overnight)
Cons
- ✗ Generates plastic waste with every use
- ✗ Can cause heat and moisture in the intimate area
- ✗ Has a recurring monthly cost
- ✗ May cause irritation on sensitive skin
- ✗ Visible under tight clothing
Newer Option
Menstrual Disc
4.5
“A modern alternative to the cup. It has a large capacity, is excellent for heavy flow, and is often comfortable for those with strong cramps.”
Pros
- ✓ Less likely to leak, even on heavy days
- ✓ Excellent for cramps, as it eases pelvic pressure
- ✓ Larger capacity than the cup
- ✓ Reusable versions available
- ✓ Can be worn for up to 12 hours
Cons
- ✗ Learning curve for insertion
- ✗ Can be a little messy to remove
- ✗ More expensive than disposable tampons
- ✗ Less available in pharmacies
Feature Comparison
Detailed side-by-side analysis
| Feature | Pad with Wings | Menstrual Disc |
|---|---|---|
| Good for a first period | Yes, a great first option | Better a bit later on |
| Usage Type | External | Internal |
| Vaginal Insertion | No | Yes (fornix) |
| Sustainability | Low | High (reusable version) |
| Wear Time | 4 to 6 hours | Up to 12 hours |
| Product Lifespan | Single use | Up to 2 years (reusable) |
| Monthly Cost | $3 to 10 | $2 to 7 (reusable) |
| Learning Curve | None | Medium |
| Best For | Beginners and heavy flow days | Heavy flow and strong cramps |
| Physical Activity | Walking and yoga (not swimming) | All activities, including swimming |
| Toxic Shock Risk | None | Very low |
| Material | Polypropylene, polyethylene, cellulose | Medical silicone or plastic (disposable) |